Why should gloomy thoughts arise. T. Hastings. [Faith.] In his Devotional Hymns, 1850, p. 87, in 3 stanzas of 8 lines. Another form of the text "O why should gloomy thoughts arise?" is in the Methodist Episcopal Hymns, 1849, in 6 stanzas of 4 lines. This indicates that the original publication has yet to be found.
--John Julian, Dictionary of Hymnology, Appendix, Part II (1907)