My Lord, my Love was crucified. J. Mason. [Sunday.] Appeared in his Spiritual Songs, or Songs of Praise, &c, 1683, No. 19, in 3 stanzas of 8 lines, and 1 stanza of 4 lines, and entitled "A Song of Praise for the Lord's Day." It is also in Sedgwick's reprint of Mason's Spiritual Songs, 1859, p. 30. It is in use in three forms: (1) The original abbreviated; (2) "My Lord, my Life, was crucified;" and (3) "Come, dearest Lord, and feed Thy sheep." The altered forms are principally in use in America.
The opening line of this hymn is well known in Church history and song. St. Ignatius used it in the first century: it was common throughout the middle ages, and the prefatory plate to Luke Boileau's Reformed Monastery, 1677, has the motto “Amor meus crucifixus est." The refrain to each stanza of C. Wesley's “O Love divine, what hast Thou done?" is "My Lord, my Love is crucified:" to each stanza of Faber's "O come and mourn with me awhile, it is "Jesus, our Love, is crucified"; and in Hymns Ancient & Modern, and most modern collections which have copied Faber's “O come and mourn with me awhile, it is "Jesus, our Lord, is crucified." It is a beautiful thought, and full of spiritual meaning. Its tenderness is not intensified by the change of "our Love" to "our Lord." [William T. Brooke]
--John Julian, Dictionary of Hymnology (1907)